A new toast for the lunch menu

Mushrooms, ricotta and thyme on sourdough. On the counter from 11 until it is gone.

Aliza Ara

3 min read

There's a new toast on the lunch menu, and it didn't come from a planning meeting. It came from the staff table at the back, where for most of last winter the team ate the same thing almost every day: mushrooms roasted until they were nearly black, piled onto sourdough with a thick layer of ricotta and far too much pepper. Eventually someone at the counter pointed at a baker's plate and said "I'll have what she's having", and we ran out of excuses.

A staff lunch

The person responsible is one of our bakers. She'd finish the morning bake, throw whatever mushrooms were in the fridge into the oven while it was still roaring hot, then build lunch standing at the bench. Within a month, half the team was doing the same, and the mushroom order had quietly tripled.

We tried adding a poached egg, some greens, a drizzle of something. Every version was a little worse than the original, so we kept it exactly as the team made it, and just made it more carefully. The sourdough is ours, cut about two fingers thick so it holds up to the last bite. Thin toast goes soggy under the ricotta.

The mushrooms

We use a mix of chestnut and oyster mushrooms, torn by hand rather than sliced, because torn edges crisp up better. Chestnut brings the deep, earthy flavour; oyster goes frilly and crunchy at the edges, almost like crackling.

Mushrooms and herbs ready on the kitchen bench

They go into a very hot oven with olive oil, garlic and thyme, and come out when the edges are almost burnt. "Almost burnt" is doing a lot of work in that sentence. A very hot oven drives off the water quickly, so the mushrooms roast instead of steaming in their own juice. A few rules:

• Don't crowd the tray, even if it means using two.
• Salt at the end, or you're back to steaming.
• Turn them once, halfway through, and otherwise leave them alone.
• Put the thyme in whole so the sprigs crisp up too.

The ricotta

Plain ricotta straight from the tub is a little grainy. Whipped with lemon zest, salt and olive oil, it goes silky, almost like a mousse, and the lemon makes it taste fresh rather than heavy. Against hot, salty, peppery mushrooms, it's the bit that makes you go back for another bite. We whip a fresh batch each morning, just before eleven, and keep it cold until it's needed.

The toast being put together in the kitchen

We spread it thick. If you can see the bread through it, ask for more.

We mean that. The ricotta isn't a garnish. It's half the toast, and whoever's on the pass has been told that a thin spread is a crime. They take it seriously.

From eleven until it's gone

Each plate is simple: dark, crisp toast, ricotta right to the edges, hot mushrooms piled on top, then olive oil, flaky salt and more black pepper than seems sensible. No egg, no salad, no balsamic. It's on the counter from 11 every day, and we make one tray of mushrooms, because that's what fits in the oven between the morning bake and the afternoon.

On Saturdays that's usually gone by one. Tuesdays are our quietest day, and the mushrooms often last until mid-afternoon.

A table for two set for lunch by the window

So come in for lunch, ask for the toast, and tell us if you can see the bread. We'll fix that straight away.

Written by

Aliza Ara

Notes from the CaféLio kitchen and counter on Cherry Lane.

A quiet corner of the café with a cup of coffee

Hungry yet?

Taste it at the counter

Everything in the journal is on the counter most days. Come early for the first tray.

KEEP

READING.

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.