Recipe

How we cook down the cherries

Sour cherries, a little sugar and a long, slow simmer. The base of the tart that never leaves the counter.

Aliza Ara

3 min read

If you've had the custard tart, you've had our cherries. If you've had the morning bun, the yoghurt bowl or, on a Friday evening, the cocktail with the dark red swirl in it, you've had them too. One pan of slow-cooked sour cherries goes into about half of what's on our counter, and it's one of the simplest things we cook: four ingredients, one pan, about an hour.

Sour, not sweet

We use sour cherries, the dark kind that make your eyes water if you eat them raw. Sweet cherries turn to jam; sour ones stay bright after an hour on the stove. Paired with a rich custard or a buttery bun, that sharpness is what stops the whole thing from tasting heavy.

In season we buy them fresh from one farm, and for a fortnight someone on the team spends every morning pitting cherries with purple hands. The rest of the year we use frozen ones from the same farm, picked and frozen the same day. They come already pitted, which the team appreciates more than they let on.

A long, slow simmer

Cherries, a little sugar, a squeeze of lemon and nothing else. They go into a wide pan on the lowest heat we have and stay there for about an hour. The wide pan lets the juice evaporate slowly, and the low heat stops the sugar catching before the fruit has softened.

Ingredients laid out on the kitchen bench

The hardest part of the whole recipe is knowing when to stop. Everyone wants to give it five more minutes. Don't.

Here's the test we use. Dip a spoon in, lift it out and run a finger through the juice on the back. If the line holds, it's ready. It will look a little loose in the pan, but it thickens a lot as it cools.

The base of everything

For the tart, a layer goes into the bottom of the pastry case before the custard, so you get a sharp red band under the soft yellow. For the morning bun, it's rolled into the dough with a little brown sugar. The Friday cocktail is a secret, mostly because it changes depending on who's behind the bar.

A cherry custard tart on the counter

We make a fresh pan every morning, and if it runs out, the tarts stop until tomorrow. We've tried bigger batches. Two pans on the go at once is how you end up with one perfect pan and one pan of jam.

Make it at home

Here's the recipe scaled down for your own kitchen. You'll need:

• 500g sour cherries, pitted (fresh or frozen, no need to thaw)
• 80g caster sugar
• Half a lemon, juiced
• A pinch of salt (optional, but we always add it)

Put the cherries, sugar and lemon juice into the widest pan you own, stir, and leave it off the heat for ten minutes so the sugar draws out the juice. Then set it on the lowest heat, lid off, and stir every few minutes, scraping the bottom. After about 45 minutes, start testing with the spoon. Frozen or very juicy cherries may need the full hour.

Add the salt, let it cool in the pan and spoon it into a clean jar. Taste halfway through, too: sour cherries vary, and some batches need a spoon more sugar.

What to do with it

It keeps for a week in the fridge. Put it on toast, in porridge, or just eat it off the spoon. Nobody's watching. It's very good with a sharp cheese, too, and a spoonful stirred into fizzy water with ice isn't the Friday cocktail, but it's not far off.

Fresh pastries from the morning bake

Or skip the washing up and come in for a slice of tart instead. The first ones are on the counter by nine, and we'll save you a corner piece if you ask nicely.

Written by

Aliza Ara

Notes from the CaféLio kitchen and counter on Cherry Lane.

A quiet corner of the café with a cup of coffee

Hungry yet?

Taste it at the counter

Everything in the journal is on the counter most days. Come early for the first tray.

KEEP

READING.

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.