Recipe

Sour-cherry tart, at home

Our most-asked recipe, scaled down for one home oven and a single tart tin.

Mara Lind

3 min read

This is our most-asked recipe. Hardly a week goes by without someone leaning over the counter, pointing at the last slice and asking how we make it. So here it is, scaled down to one 23cm tart tin and a home oven. It comes in three parts, pastry, custard and cherries, and each one can be done a little ahead. Most of it is waiting.

What you'll need

A tin with a loose base is the only thing worth buying, so you can push the tart up and out without breaking the sides. Take the eggs out of the fridge when you start. Keep the butter in.

• For the pastry: 200g plain flour, 120g cold unsalted butter, 40g icing sugar, a pinch of salt and 1 egg yolk.
• For the custard: 2 whole eggs and 2 yolks, 300ml double cream, 60g caster sugar and a little vanilla.
• For the cherries: 400g sour cherries, pitted (frozen are fine).
• 50g caster sugar and a squeeze of lemon.
• 1 level teaspoon of cornflour, mixed with a spoonful of water.

The pastry

Rub the butter into the flour, icing sugar and salt quickly, with your fingertips, until there are no big lumps left. Quickly is the important word. Warm hands make tough pastry, which is why our baker runs hers under the cold tap first. Add the yolk, bring it into a ball, adding cold water a teaspoon at a time if it won't hold, then flatten it into a disc and chill it for an hour.

Roll it thin, about the thickness of a coin, and line the tin, leaving a little overhang to trim after baking. Prick the base, line it with baking paper and beans and blind-bake it at 180°C for about 15 minutes, then another 8 to 10 without the beans, until it's the colour of a biscuit.

Pastry being rolled out on a floured counter

The custard

While the case is in the oven, whisk the eggs, yolks, cream, sugar and vanilla. Whisk gently. You want it smooth, not frothy, or the top will bake with a layer of bubbles. Turn the oven down to 150°C and pour the custard into the warm case. Warm matters: it starts setting the bottom straight away and keeps the pastry crisp.

Take it out while the middle still wobbles. It sets as it cools, and trusting that is most of the recipe.

Bake for about 30 minutes, until the middle wobbles like a jelly that's been nudged. If it's firm all the way across in the oven, it will be rubbery on the plate. Start checking at 25 minutes, then let it cool for at least two hours.

A baked custard tart cooling on a rack

The cherries

Put the cherries, sugar and lemon in a small pan over a medium heat and let them bubble for about 10 minutes, until the juice has reduced by half. Stir in the cornflour and cook for one more minute, until it's glossy and thick enough to sit on a spoon. Leave them to cool completely. They should still be a little sharp. That sharpness is what stops the tart tasting like pudding.

Spoon them over the tart once it's completely cool, never while it's warm, or the custard weeps. That's the one rule. We've broken it, more than once, usually because someone was hungry. The result tastes fine and looks like a crime scene.

Sour cherries spooned over a custard tart

Serving and keeping

Serve it the same day, at room temperature, with nothing else on the plate. No cream, no ice cream, no mint leaf. It doesn't need help. If you must keep it, store the tart and the cherries separately in the fridge and put them together the next day. Nobody has ever complained to us about a day-old slice.

If yours comes out looking nothing like ours, don't worry. Ours didn't either, the first dozen times, and there's usually a slice on the counter until about two if you want to compare notes.

Written by

Mara Lind

Notes from the CaféLio kitchen and counter on Cherry Lane.

A quiet corner of the café with a cup of coffee

Hungry yet?

Taste it at the counter

Everything in the journal is on the counter most days. Come early for the first tray.

KEEP

READING.

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.